Wood fired or electric: an honest comparison

The romance, the running costs, the smoke control rules almost nobody mentions, and which one you will actually use on a Tuesday in February. Including the parts that are inconvenient for us to say.

Wood fired or electric: an honest comparison
Wood fired or electric: an honest comparison

This is the decision most people agonise over, and both are good. They are good at different things, and the right one for you depends far less on which heats a room better in the abstract and far more on how you actually intend to use it, where you live, and how much ritual you want in your evening.

What follows is the comparison we would give a friend.

The short version

Wood fired Electric
Heat up time Typically 45 to 90 minutes Typically 30 to 60 minutes
Effort per session Real: lighting, feeding, ash Effectively none
Running cost Cost of logs, no meter Metered, and easy to calculate
Electrical work needed Usually none Usually a dedicated supply
Siting constraints Flue, clearances, smoke rules Cable route only
Spontaneous use Poor Excellent
The experience Hard to beat Very good, quieter

Two matching sauna cabins, one with a flue and a log stack, the other wired back to the house

The case for wood

The heat is different. That is not romance, it is physics: a wood stove produces a more radiant, drier heat with a rolling quality to it, and the sound and the smell are a genuine part of why people love saunas. If you have a garden with space, and the ritual is the point, wood fired is a very hard thing to argue against.

It also frees you from the grid. No supply to install, no cable to route, nothing to trip. For a garden at the end of a long plot, or a cabin somewhere without easy power, wood is sometimes the only sensible answer rather than the romantic one.

Two cabins in the current outdoor range can be ordered with a wood burning heater instead of an electric one, and both are four person barrels: the Harvia Kuusi 180 Panorama and the Harvia Kaski 180 Panorama. They are also the range's clearest comparison of sauna timbers, the same 40mm stave wall in untreated spruce on one and thermally modified pine on the other. Both pages specify the same stove, the Harvia Linear 18, which Harvia rate for rooms of 5 to 18 cubic metres and supply with its steel chimney kit for barrel saunas, protective bedding and 40kg of stones. On the point that decides this page for a good number of people, Harvia's wording is that it needs no heater circuit at all.

A stove does need combustion air, which an electric element does not, and Harvia position the cabin's vents differently for the two. Our guide to whether a sauna needs ventilation sets out both arrangements, and names chimney fitting as a trade you book rather than one that arrives with the cabin.

The case against wood

It is a commitment. Somebody has to lay it, light it, and come back to feed it. Somebody has to clear the ash and sweep the flue. And crucially, somebody has to decide forty minutes before they want to use it that they want to use it. On a Tuesday in February, when the honest choice is between a sauna and the sofa, that forty minutes decides more sessions than people expect.

There is also a legal point that is very often missed.

Smoke control areas: check before you buy

Large parts of urban and suburban Britain are designated smoke control areas. In one, you cannot emit smoke from a chimney, and government guidance is explicit that roofed garden structures with a chimney are covered by the same rule as the house. A garden sauna with a flue is exactly that kind of structure.

In a smoke control area you may only burn authorised fuels, unless the appliance itself is on the Defra exempt appliance list. Very few sauna stoves appear on that list. In England the penalty for emitting smoke from a chimney in a smoke control area can run to three hundred pounds, and buying unauthorised fuel for a non approved appliance carries a larger one.

Two phone calls, before you spend anything: your council, and the stove manufacturer.

Ask your local council whether your address is in a smoke control area. If it is, ask the manufacturer whether that specific stove model is Defra exempt, and get the answer in writing. This is not an obscure risk, it is a fifteen minute check that occasionally saves someone several thousand pounds. We would rather you did it than found out afterwards.

The case for electric

You press a button. Forty minutes later it is ready, and it is ready whether or not you feel like being a person who lays a fire. For most people, most of the time, that is the difference between a sauna used twice a week for ten years and a sauna used enthusiastically for one summer.

Electric heaters are also easier to site, easier to control precisely, and available with timers and remote start, which turns a forty minute wait into something you begin on your way home. In a smaller garden, or anywhere near neighbours, the absence of smoke removes a whole category of problem.

Most of the outdoor cabins we sell arrive this way. On the Kuusi 180 Panorama the electric version carries the Harvia Wall SW80, 8kW, and whichever heater you choose is included in the one price, which is the shape this decision usually takes in practice: the heater comes with the cabin, and the question is what your consumer unit can give it. Which heaters a cabin offers at all varies by model rather than by shape, so check the options on the model you are drawn to before you settle the fuel question.

What electric costs to run

This one you can calculate, which is a mercy. Take the heater rating in kilowatts, multiply by hours of use, multiply by your unit rate.

Under the Ofgem price cap for 1 October to 31 December 2026, electricity is capped at 26.32 pence per kilowatt hour for a typical direct debit customer, with no VAT charged on household electricity under the cap between 1 October 2026 and 31 March 2027. A six kilowatt heater running for one hour at that rate is roughly one pound fifty eight of electricity. The cap in force to 30 September 2026 was 26.11 pence per kilowatt hour including VAT, so the same hour cost roughly one pound fifty seven.

In practice the heater draws full power while heating and then cycles to hold temperature, so a session of one hour of heating plus an hour of use typically lands somewhere between one and two pounds, depending on insulation, weather and how hot you like it. Insulation quality moves that number far more than heater brand does. Our guide to what a sauna costs to run in the UK takes Harvia's published session and annual consumption figures and works them through at the current cap rate.

What wood costs to run

Harder to pin down, because it depends entirely on what you pay for logs. A session typically burns somewhere in the region of ten to fifteen kilos of dry hardwood. If you buy seasoned logs by the crate the cost per session is often broadly comparable to electric. If you have access to your own wood it is close to free. If you buy small bags from a garage forecourt it is considerably more expensive than electric, which surprises people.

Whatever you burn, it must be properly dry. Wood sold in England in units under two cubic metres has to be certified to 20 per cent moisture or less and carry the Ready to Burn mark, and that is law rather than advice. Wet wood produces less heat, more smoke and more tar in the flue, and it is the single commonest reason a wood fired sauna underperforms.

How to actually decide

Three questions settle it for most people.

  • How often do you realistically want to use it? Two or three times a week, spontaneously, points hard at electric. Once or twice a week as a deliberate occasion points at wood.
  • Are you in a smoke control area? If yes, and the stove you want is not Defra exempt, the decision has been made for you.
  • How far is the cabin from your consumer unit, and what can that consumer unit give it? A long cable run through a mature garden is a real cost, and across the outdoor range the dedicated circuit runs from 20 to 50 amps. What electrical supply a garden sauna needs covers reading the rating on your main fuse. Get a rough electrician's figure before you commit either way.

There is no wrong answer here, only a wrong fit. If you tell us your garden, your access, your address and roughly how you picture using it, we will tell you which way we would go and why, including when the answer is the cheaper one.

If you are earlier in the process than this, our outdoor sauna buying guide takes the five decisions in the order they have to be made, what size sauna heater do I need works the kilowatts through, and planning permission for a garden sauna sets out the height limits.

Sources

  • Smoke control area rules and penalties: GOV.UK. gov.uk/smoke-control-area-rules
  • Defra exempt appliances, listed by nation. smokecontrol.defra.gov.uk
  • Wood fuel moisture and the Ready to Burn mark: GOV.UK. gov.uk
  • Chimney sweeping frequency: HETAS. hetas.co.uk
  • Electricity price cap unit rates and standing charges, with the period stated beside each figure: Ofgem, 1 October to 31 December 2026 rates read 1 October 2026. ofgem.gov.uk
  • Wood burning heater option, model, rating and what ships with it: the specifications published on the Harvia Kuusi 180 Panorama and Harvia Kaski 180 Panorama product pages, read 25 September 2026.
The Tarnfell Journal

Worth opening.

Saunas, cold plunges, honest buying advice and first word on new arrivals. No spam, unsubscribe any time.